A difficulty score vs looking at the results yourself
Tool difficulty score
- Quick filter across thousands of terms
- Mostly based on links to ranking pages
- Scales differ between tools
- Ignores how well pages match intent
Manual results check
- Slow, so use it on a shortlist
- Shows forums or thin pages ranking
- Reveals intent and format
- Compares rivals to your own site
Step 1: Pull keyword difficulty data from your tool
Enter your target keyword in the Keyword Explorer or equivalent. Every major SEO tool provides a difficulty score — usually on a 0-100 scale. Note that each tool calculates it differently, so compare scores within the same tool, not between tools.
Tool for this stepMangools
from $49/moKWFinder's difficulty score is colour-coded and shown next to a SERP overview with link metrics for the ranking pages, which makes the score easier to act on.
Mangools plans and catchesAlternative to consider: Ubersuggest (price not verified)
Step 2: Cross-reference the SERP manually
The most reliable way to assess difficulty is to look at the actual SERP. Are the top results from DA 70+ sites with thousands of backlinks? Or do you see forums, small blogs, or sites weaker than yours? The SERP always beats the score.
Tool for this stepLowFruits
from $29.90/moLowFruits automates SERP weakness detection: it scans SERPs in bulk and flags keywords where weak pages rank. It removes the manual SERP-checking bottleneck.
LowFruits plans and catchesAlternative to consider: Mangools (from $49/mo)
Step 3: Compare your domain strength to what's ranking
Check your own Domain Rating or Domain Authority and compare it to the average DR of the top 10 results for your keyword. If the top 10 average DR is 60 and yours is 20, you'll need exceptional content and links to compete. If the average is 25 and yours is 20, you have a real shot.
Tool for this stepAhrefs
from £23/moAhrefs' Keywords Explorer shows a SERP overview with the DR of each ranking page next to the keyword's difficulty score. Moz's Keyword Explorer offers a similar view using Domain Authority.
Ahrefs plans and catchesAlternative to consider: Moz Pro (from $99/mo)
Step 4: Use difficulty filters to build a winnable keyword list
Set difficulty thresholds based on your domain strength: DR 0-20: target KD 0-15. DR 20-40: target KD 0-25. DR 40-60: target KD 0-40. These are rough guidelines — always validate with the SERP. Build a filtered list and prioritise the highest volume opportunities within your range.
Tool for this stepSemrush
from $139/moSemrush's Keyword Magic Tool lets you set exact KD ranges as filters, narrowing a large keyword list to the ones that are realistic targets for your site right now.
Semrush plans and catchesAlternative to consider: KeySearch (from $24/mo)